The Peter Lynch Crayon Test Could Save Your Investment Portfolio

Peter Lynch, the gentleman that achieved 29% annual returns while running Fidelity’s Magellan Fund from 1977 through 1990, is famous for saying that you should never invest in any idea that you can’t illustrate with a crayon. A variation of this advice is that you should never own a business where it takes more than a few sentences to explain how the company turns a profit.

The highest-quality businesses can usually be explained quite simply.

Coca-Cola makes its profits by making syrup concentrates that allow them to make about $0.30 or so on every dollar once it is said and done.

Hershey sells chocolate in varying serving sizes in such a way that the company can achieve 16% total returns on assets.

Philip Morris International manufactures cigarettes for pennies per pack, and sells them for $5-$10 per pack.

Procter & Gamble sells household products like Tide Laundry Detergent, Gillette razors, and Duracell batteries. It has so many products that 398 out of every 400 American homes contain a product somewhere that is manufactured by P&G.

Pepsi sells soft drinks, snacks, and breakfast foods, leveraging a diversified stream of profits from soda, Quaker Oats, and Frito-Lay to create lasting profits even in the worst of recessions.

Colgate-Palmolive sells toothpaste and dish soap in a way that allows it to achieve 30% or so returns on equity, which explains why the company has been making dividend payments every year dating back to 1895.

Wal-Mart sells hundreds of billions of dollars of merchandise each year while collecting about 3% or so in net profit on each item after it is all said and done, and the high volume churn explains why the company is able to make such substantial profits for its shareholder owners.

McDonalds well franchise its hamburger joint out to individual managers, who have to pay substantial rent and a percentage of costs to the parent company. This allows the company to profit immensely from every fast food operation while limiting the downside associated with restaurants that do not perform well.

Now explain to me exactly how Citigroup and Linn Energy generate each dollar of profit. See what I mean?

Peter Lynch’s crayon test is a variation of Warren Buffett’s advice to know your circle of competence when it comes to investing, and always stay within that circle. Peter Lynch’s crayon test is a nice metaphor that allows you to refocus on owning companies that generate profits you can easily understand.

If you scroll through your current stock holdings, could you easily explain why you own each one of them?

I’m probably the dumbest investor out there. There are only one hundred or so companies out of 15,000+ whose profits I easily understand, and feel I can reasonably predict going forward. But sticking with the Johnson & Johnson’s and Nestle’s of the world is no confinement. They compound wealth just fine. Having a narrow circle of competence is no problem when you’re building. It’s the ability to honestly acknowledge what you do understand and do not understand that makes all the difference.

After all, if you do not understand how Gilead Sciences makes its profits, do you really think you’d be able to hold on if the stock fell 50?

On the other hand, Coca-Cola could fall to $20 per share, and I’d be able to walk through Wal-Mart and see the Coca-Cola flying off the shelves. I’d see the Coca-Cola trucks on the highway. I’d be able to read the financial reports about how the company has 500+ beverage brands making over $10 billion in annual profits in just about every country in the world. When you understand a company on that level, it is much easier to not only withstand substantial stock price declines, but treat them as the opportunities that they are to buy more.



Originally posted 2013-08-07 17:13:29.

Like this general content? Join The Conservative Income Investor on Patreon for discussion of specific stocks!

7 thoughts on “The Peter Lynch Crayon Test Could Save Your Investment Portfolio

  1. joni repasch says:

    Great post, Tim, and equally good advice.

    I hold most of the good companies you mentioned about: Still waiting for Wal-Mart and Colgate-Palmolive to reach my comfort level and cash holdings. Not there yet on either level.

    Unfortunately, I used to own Citi Group back in 2007-2012, and bought LINN this spring. The only thing I know about LINN is it does a lot of hedging ;-). Both were absolute disasters.

    I never had the pleasure of meeting Peter Finch but the husband of a dear from of mine went to work for Finch at Fidelity back in early 85 I believe. David's, my friend husband, also left Fidelity with Finch when Finch started his hedge fund in circa 1900. David made his millions with Finch and left the company in 2005. Dave now owns two cupcake stores near Boston and never looks at the market or his portfolio except at tax time. At least that's what he told me the last we spoke. I guess Finch still runs that hedge fund or David wouldn't be so blasé.

  2. Larry.Livingston says:

    Joni, you mean Lynch, not Finch, don't you? 😉

    Good advice Tim, I currently hold all of them in my portfolio except WMT… instead of WMT I own GILD… 😉

  3. says:

    One thing Lynch also highlighted is that different people have different expertises, hobbies, and work, so they will know certain businesses better than the folks in Street or other investor (“local knowledge'' as used by Lynch). It is quite possible that one may know a certain business that may not be well understood or appreciated by others.

    That said you should still be able to explain what the niche or less-well-known business simply. So if you know cat and dog food business, animation business, toy business, furniture making business, or trucking business that are doing well with their stock price looks good, go for it!

  4. Cami Halısı Nereden Alınır? Cami halısı fiyatları, halının üretildiği malzeme yapısına, boyutuna göre değişiklik gösterir. Aradığınız tüm özelliklere sahip olan, kaliteli malzemelerden üretilen ve uzun yıllar boyu rahatlıkla kullanabileceğiniz bir cami halısı almayı düşünüyor iseniz Manisa’nın Demirci ilçesinde bulunan ve tüm Türkiye’ye hizmet veren Selçuklu Cami Halısı Cami Halıları internet sitemizi ziyaret edebilir ya da iletişim hattımızdan bize ulaşarak cami halısı fiyat bilgilerini kolaylıkla öğrenebilirsiniz.

  5. says:

    I have read your article carefully and I agree with you very much. This has provided a great help for my thesis writing, and I will seriously improve it. However, I don’t know much about a certain place. Can you help me?

  6. says:

    Cool. I spent a long time looking for relevant content and found that your article gave me new ideas, which is very helpful for my research. I think my thesis can be completed more smoothly. Thank you.

Leave a Reply