Kimberly-Clark Stock Is Finally Fairly Priced

There are about a dozen large-cap publicly traded businesses that I have wanted to cover in depth, but have perpetually declined to do so because I wanted to wait for an opportunity for the stock price to be fair (or better). Kimberly-Clark has now reached such a price point at $104 per share.

On the consumer side, Kimberly-Clark is most famous for being the diaper maker that is responsible for Huggies, Pull-Ups, GoodNites, Kotex, Lightdays, Depend, Poise, and Little Swimmers as well as tissue brands such as Kleenex and Viva (Kleenex is one of those brands that has proven so successful that people don’t customarily ask for a tissue but rather say ‘Gimme a Kleenex.’”

These brands, as you might expect, are stodgy and recession-resistant. It doesn’t matter what the economy throws at you; you’re going to pay an extra $0.40 for Kleenex rather than the generic tissue.

My problem is that, as amazing as it is that Kimberly-Clark actually grew its profits during the last recession from $1.6 billion in 2008 to $1.8 billion in 2009 to $1.9 billion in 2010, Kimberly-Clark has long shared the characteristics that I associate with the food stocks.

Its portfolio largely consists of mature brands in established markets, and that means you have to get the price right. After all, revenues of $19.4 billion in 2008 are actually lower compared to $18.6 billion today. When there is no top-line growth, a lowered lid exists on your investment returns. You are not going to compound at 15% per year for fifteen years.

But, if you get the price right, you can own a market-dominant collection of assets that stands a fair chance of delivering 9-10% annual returns.

For most of the past five years, the Kimberly-Clark P/E ratio has been too high. I couldn’t believe that the stock price hit $138 per share in 2016 even though earnings were only at $6 per share. It is hard to build wealth paying 23x earnings for a business with no-top line growth. Over the past five years, Kimberly Clark has an average P/E ratio of 20.4.

Quietly, Kimberly-Clark has seen its stock price fall from the $130s in May 2017 to the low $100s today. At a current price of $104 per share, Kimberly-Clark offers a far better trade-off than at any point in its recent history. With Kimberly-Clark slated to earn $7 per share in profits this year, the valuation is 14.8x earnings. Investors haven’t seen that level since 2010.

I am intrigued. Even during the period of no revenue growth, Kimberly-Clark still grew core earnings at 3.5%. The dividend yield is 3.8%. And Kimberly-Clark repurchases 1% of its stock each. Even if the sluggish status quo persists, you can get your hands on an all-weather stock that can generate 8.3% total returns. My own expectation is that Kimberly-Clark will modestly grow revenues which will also modestly raise the P/E ratio and give investors that purchase Kimberly-Clark stock in 2018 a reasonable chance of earning 10% annual returns through 2028. Given how reliably stable the earnings stream is, that upside is worthy of consideration.

This seems like the investment season for giving the Kraft-Heinzes, General Millses, and Kimberley-Clarks of the world a fair look. These portfolio staples were just too highly priced in recent years to support any kind of meaningful investment. And during recessions, it is the high-quality companies that have fallen on short-term crisis that tend to deserve the most attention. If your portfolio has acquired too much tech, cyclical, and financial industry exposure in recent years, now is a great time to direct future cash flows towards those ‘ole reliable steady businesses that have transitioned from overvaluation to fair pricing.

This is a publicly available version of an article shared with The Conservative Income Investor’s Patreon followers on May 24, 2018.

Like this general content? Join The Conservative Income Investor on Patreon for discussion of specific stocks!